37. Judgments or orders or decrees, other than those mentioned in sections 34, 35 and 36, are irrelevant, unless the existence of such judgment, order or decree is a fact in issue, or is relevant under some other provision of this Adhiniyam. Illustrations. (a) A and B separately sue C for a libel which reflects upon each of them. C in each case says that the matter alleged to be libellous is true, and the circumstances are such that it is probably true in each case, or in neither. A obtains a decree against C for damages on the ground that C failed to make out his justification. The fact is irrelevant as between B and C. (b) A prosecutes B for stealing a cow from him. B is convicted. A afterwards sues C for the cow, which B had sold to him before his conviction. As between A and C, the judgment against B is irrelevant. (c) A has obtained a decree for the possession of land against B. C, B's son, murders A in consequence. The existence of the judgment is relevant, as showing motive for a crime. (d) A is charged with theft and with having been previously convicted of theft. The previous conviction is relevant as a fact in issue. (e) A is tried for the murder of B. The fact that B prosecuted A for libel and that A was convicted and sentenced is relevant under section 6 as showing the motive for the fact in issue.
Evidence Act Section 43 in BSA: Section 37
Judgments, etc., other than those mentioned in sections 40 to 42, when relevant
Section 43 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 (Judgments, etc., other than those mentioned in sections 40 to 42, when relevant) corresponds to Section 37 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023, in force from 1 July 2024.
Ask on WhatsApp, free, no signup:
Text of BSA Section 37
Full BSA Section 37 and every Evidence Act section it replaced →
Ask CaseMinister about Evidence Act 43 / BSA 37
Your 24×7 legal assistant on WhatsApp answers with the judgments that apply, in English or Hindi. No signup needed.