CaseMinister
CaseMinister › Judgments › Supreme Court › 2009 › Madan Lal v. Hardeep Kaur

Madan Lal v. Hardeep Kaur

Supreme Court of India · 6 February 2009

Court
Supreme Court of India
Decided
6 February 2009
Case no.
C.A. No. 763 of 2009
Bench
Tarun Chatterjee, H.L. Dattu
Length
6 pages
Have a question about this judgment?

Ask our Legal AI about it on WhatsApp: free, no signup, in English or Hindi.

Write it first.

         


                       

 
    
           

 
     
             
    ! "  #$  %
 & ’            %     ’

( )( ! 
(* 
+   ,,- **( !$

   

( ) - -,  . (#

+ - , !) - !$



/
- (0 -  "( ! $- ) 

2.
1   ( , , - (*    )   - 2$- )  ("(  ! $ (  %!( *   ) -

)( $- )  /
$1
 % 2$  3- 4      , ( - )  35  (

*- ( ! -)   #)" -  % $1-  " 1 #  $ % # !6 ( 3 ( ! )

( 5 ( !(  ($  1( ! ) "( 1   !   0 *  -0    !  ( -

   7   %    


1 -   - , !) - !$  ( ) -- ,  . (#  1( )  % *- )  ( !

-0 2 $ !  , - $$  !  #!)-   -2 $  !  /  % $1-

( $  # !6 ( 3  3(!   -!$   - $   2$ !  2 $4 / 8 

1 -  (,, - **(! $  -!$ -  - )  (, , -(  ( ! 2-  3-% -  $1-

- !$    ! $ **- 4   1(! )  "( 14  (!)  %*- )  1

9 $ $-!
 $ ( $-: - !$  )- ! 5! "  $1-  :( $-  ( *

(* *- "($  ! :( ) - !  $1-  -0 2$ !  , -$ $  !  

8
1 -  $ ( *   # $  1()  %(: - )   #- 4  ! -  %

912 1  9(  91-$ 1-  $1-  #  $  ,  -:  -  9(

- ;#  - )  3! ( % )-  %  $1-  ,# ,  -  % ,-   ! ( *

!- 2-  $5 % $1-   - ,  !) -! $   # 3 - ;# - ! $ $

$1-  % *! "   % $1-  9  $$- !  $( $- : - ! $4  $1-

(, ,- **( !$

( * 

%*- ) 
( : - !) - ) 
9 $$- !

$ ($ - :- !$ <2 #! $-

2*(  :4

) - ! 5! "

$1-

- *( $ ! 1,  % *(! ) * )  ( ! )  $-! ( ! $ (  9-* *

(  3!(  %)-   -;#   - :- !$  % $1- - , ! ) - !$ 

5.
5  (!  ) -   ) ( $- )  / 8$1 % #! - 4    =4 $1-   - ! $

 !$  * *-  4  1 ( !) " ( 1  1( )  ( ** 9-)
 $1-

-0 2 $ !  ,-$  $ !  ( !)   ) - - )  -0 2 $ !  % $1-

(, ,- **( !$    " " -0 -)  35 $1-  (% - ( )  ) -

% $1-  - ! $   !$  * *-  4 $1-  ( ,,- **( !$  %*- )

(!  (, , - (*  3- % -  $1-    $  2$  # )" - 4  !  !

-   $ 5 4  1( ! ) "(  1   #  ! "  $1-  ,- !) - !2 5

%  $1-  (, , -( *4  $1-  (,, - **(! $  %* -)  (!

(, ,*  2( $  !  %  (22 - ,$ ( ! 2-  %  () ) $ !( *

-0 ) - !2 -  #!) -    )-   8/   #*-     % $1-  ) -

%  0 *    2- )#  -  >!  1 $ ?$ 1-   )- @A

1 - 
  $ 2 $ 
 #)" - 4 
 !   ! 
-  $   54

1 (! ) " ( 1  #3 -; #- !$ *54  35  ( !  ) -   ) ( $- )

/8 $1 % -, $- : 3- 4    4 ) :  - )  $1-  (, ,- (*

% $1- (, , -* *( ! $  


1 -  ( , , -* *( ! $4  $1- -( %$-  4  : 0-)  $1-  2 0 *

- 0  !  2( -  3-  !"    0 *  - 0   !  ( -   

 7  %  
 3- %-  $1-   "1 #  $ 912 14 35

$1-   : , #"!- )   )-  4  9(  ( *   -6 - 2$- ) 

- -*  !"  (" " - 0-) 4 $1-  (, ,- **(! $ 1(  2 :-  #,

35 9(5  % (  , - 2 ( *
- (0 -  -$  $  !  $  $1

 # $4 912 1  !  " ( !$  % *- (0 - 4 9(  1-( )   !

$1-  ,- - !2 -  % $1-  *- ( !- )  2 #! - * %  $1-

,( $  -   


( 0 ! "  1- ( )  $1-  *- ( ! - )  2 #! - *  %  $1-

,( $  -  (! )  -B( : !- )  $1-  : ,# "! - )  ) -   (

9- ** (  $1-   $1-   :( $-  (*  !  -2  ) 4 !   #

0 -9 4 $1-   )-   , ( - )  35 $1-   "1   # $  !

- 0  !  2( -    * (3 *-  $  3-  - $ (  )-  !  (

:, *-  " # ! )  
   ,* (  !   - ( ) ! "  %  $1-

: ,# "!- )    ) -  9 #*)  1 9 $1( $ $1-  - 0  !

2( -  9(  -6 - 2$- )  35 $1-   "1   # $  !* 5  !

$1-  " #! )  $1( $ $1-  (, ,- **( ! $ 1( )  %(*- )  $

3 ! "  $  $1-  ! $ 2-  % $1-   #$  $1($  $1-

(, ,*  2( $  !  #! ) -   )-   8/  # *-    % $1-

 )-  9(  -6 - 2$-)  35 $1-  , ,- **( $-  # $1  $54

(* $1 #"1  $1-  ( ,,- **( !$  1( )  $( C-!  (  ,* -(

3- % -  $1-   "1    #$  $1( $  # 21  (!

(, ,*  2( $  !  1( 0 ! " 3-- !  %* -) 4 9(  !  $ ($  ( **

$( C-!   !$   2 !  ) -  ($   !  35  $1-   $ 2 $

# )" - 4 3-  !"  $1-   , ,- **( $-   #$1   $5   $ 

! *5 !  $1  "# ! )  $1($  $1-  20  * - 0   !

2( -  9(  -6 - 2$- )  35 $1-   "1   # $   $

$ #-  $1( $ $1-  ( ,, * 2( $  !  #!) -     )-   8/   #*-

   % $1-    ) - 4 %*- )  35 $1-  (,, - **(! $4 9(

- 6- 2$- )  35 $1-  *-(  !- )   $  2$  #)" - 4 !  !

-   $ 5 4 
 1( !)  "( 1 4 
3#$ 
$1- 
) -

) :  ! " $1-  (, ,- ( * )  )  !$  1 9 $1($  $1-  -

9(  ( ! 5   -%- - !2 -  : ()-  $  $1-  - 6- 2$ !   %

$1-  ( , , * 2($  !  % $1-  ( ,,- **(! $ %*- )  #!) -

 )-   8/  #* -     % $1-  ) -      ,- # ( * %

$1-    ) -   % $1-   , ,- **( $-  # $1   $5  9 #*)

(*   1 9 $1($  $1-  (,, * 2($  !  #! ) -   ) -  8/

# *-      % $1-   )-  9(  -6 - 2$-)  !  $1-  ( : -

)( $-  3#$ 35 (  - , ( ($ -   ) - 4  912 1 9(  ! $

9 $1 !  $1-  C! 9*- )" -   % $1-  ( ,,- **( !$  ( $ $1-

$ :-  $1-  !$  2-  9(   #-)  35 $1-  " 1 #  $

-! $-  $( !  !"  $1-  - 0  !( *  ( ,,*  2( $ ! 

0 -!  ( #: ! " $1( $ $1-  %(2$  % #2 1  - 6-2 $ !

9(  !$  3# "1$  $  $1-  ! $ 2-  % $1-   "1

 # $4 $  2 #*)  !  $ *- ( )  $   -6- 2$ !   % $1-

2 0 * -0    !  2( -  9 $1 #$ ) -2 )  ! " $1-  (: -

!  : - $     1- - %- 4 $1-   "1  #$  9(  !  $

6# $  %-)   !   -6- 2$ !"  $1-  2 0*  - 0  !

2( -  9 $1# $  "  ! "  !$   $1-  :-   $  (  $

91-$ 1-  $1-   - ,  ! ) -! $  9(  -! $$ *- )  $  (!

 )-    % - 0 2$ !   !  $1-  "  #!)  $1( $  1-

- ;#  - )  $1-  #$  , -:  -  %  1-   9 !  # -

(! )  22 #, ( $ !                 

7
!  $1  0-9  % $1-  : ( $$- 4 9-  - $ ( ) -  $1-

 )-   % $1-  "1   # $  (!)  -!)  $1-  2( -

3( 2C $  $  %  %- 1 ) ,  (*  !  ( 22  ) (! 2-

9 $1  *( 9   1-   "1   # $    -; #- $- )  $

) ,  -  % $1-  :( $$-   9 $1 !  $1 - -  : !$ 1

%:  $1-  )($ -   % 2 : :# ! 2( $ !  % (  2, 5  %

$1
  )-   9$ 1# $  "( !$ ! "  #!!- 2- (  5

() 6 #! :- ! $  $  -$ 1-   % $1-  ,( $  -   


1 -  (,, - ( *    $1#  (**  9-)  $  $1-  -B$- ! $

! ) 2($ -)  (3 0 -    1 - -  9 ** 3-  !   )-   (

$  2 $    

+ + + + + + + + + + +  

                 ’

  D  
E                                 ++
+
+ + + + + + + +  
      F

  4

  
 
       ’

Ask CaseMinister about Madan Lal v. Hardeep Kaur

Your 24×7 legal assistant on WhatsApp answers with the judgments that apply, in English or Hindi. No signup needed.

Questions about this judgment, or a case like it?Ask on WhatsApp