CaseMinister
CaseMinister › Judgments › Supreme Court › 2009 › M/S Mohinder Singh & Co. v. Board of Trustees of the Port of

M/S Mohinder Singh & Co. v. Board of Trustees of the Port of Bombay

Supreme Court of India · 27 January 2009

Court
Supreme Court of India
Decided
27 January 2009
Case no.
C.A. No. 448 of 2009
Bench
Tarun Chatterjee, H.L. Dattu
Length
3 pages
Have a question about this judgment?

Ask our Legal AI about it on WhatsApp: free, no signup, in English or Hindi.

Does it help my case?Later judgments on this

Write it first.

         


                       

 
    
           

 
     
           
        ! "# ! $
 % &  !   ’ ( ’  )  ! $     &

*   !+   , -   + .  ! 
                  /
0 0- 112#

   

! 2 ,  !$    "# --   !$  #+-  ! #  !$  ! 3425
/ -  0! , - #



’
- 26-  2  #- , 

2.
+   200- 21     , - 7#- ,  2 2 #  #+-  $ 21

! ,-   ,2# - ,  
#+ !$   - 7-3 4- 8    9 02 - ,  45 2

 6  !   - 7+  ! $  #+-   +  ! "#  ! $

" , 72#" -  2# !3 425     00-2 1   !   ’ ’(  ! $

’  8  : + 7+  2 ! -  !" #  !$  2   4 # 2# !

- # #!    !  ;   ! $  ’ ( 8  45  : +7 +  #+-

 6  !   -  7+ +2,   -$ " -,  #!   2 # # - -  #

#!  #+-  200- 112#  !   2 " 3 !$  
 ; 8  8  *<

= +  #5 
27 >  2:2  , - ,  45  #+-  1-2   - ,

 4 #2 #!   $! 3 #+-  , 2#-  !$  , -7 - -   -  ’ #+

!$  "  - 8  ’     #1 1  0253- #  !  - 21 ?2# ! 

+ -  30 " - ,  ! , -   !$  #+-  6   !  - 7 + ! $

#+-   + !"  # "   2  ",-   @<

A !  ! , -  !  20 01 72#! B 

;
#     #+-  2$! - 2 ,  ! ,-  8  :+  7+    ", -

7+211- -  4- $!  -  "    C-  +26-  +-2 ,  #+-

1- 2  -,  7! " - 1  $!   #+-  02 # -  2 ,  2$#-

!   #+ !" + #+-   30"  - ,  !  ,-  8 : -  2 -  ! $

#+-  6- :  #+2# #+-  ! ,-   ! $ #+-   + !"  #

1 241-  #!  4-  - # 2  ,-  !  #+-   ! ",  #+2#  #

:2   !#  2 0 -2 D  !  2 -2  !  -,  ! ,-   2,

#+-  30 " - ,  ! , -   :2
 02 - ,  :  #+!" #

20015   #  3,  
 + -  1-2  -,  7! " - 1

200- 2
 !
 4- +21$  !$  #+-  -  0! , - #

+!:- 6- 8 , 2 :  !"   2##- # !   #!  #+-  3-  #  !$

#+-  02 5-   !$  #+-  200- 112 #  2 ,  #+-

7! # - , -,  #+2# #+-  200- 112 # :2   !#  - ## 1- ,

#!   2 -  #+-   2,  025 -   2  #+-  2: 2,  #+2#

:2   02  - ,  45  #+-   4 # 2#!   : 2   !#

7+211- - ,  45  #+-  200- 112#    C-  2-   ! #

71 - ,  #!  !    #!  #+   E"- #!   2  #+-   2 ,

E"- #!   72  4-  !  -  # !  45 #+-   +   !" #

:+ 1 -  , - 7,
 #+-  02 5-   $!   2 #  !$

#-  - #  $! 3  #+-  , 2#-  ! $  #+-  ,- 7 - -  # 11

0253- #  !   -2 1? 2# !   


7 7!  ,  158  ! 15  !   #+-   ! ",  #+2#  #+-

! ,-   : 2  ! # 2 0- 2D  2 ,  2  -2 !  - ,  ! ,-

2 ,  #+-  2 3-  :2   02 - ,  :# +! "# 20015   #

3 , 8 #+-  3 0"  - ,  ! , -     - # 2  ,-    + -

+  ! " #    -E"- # - ,  #!  ,- 7 , -  #+-  0 25-

32,-  45 #+-  200- 112#     277!  ,2  7-  :# + 12:

2$#-    6  +-2    #!  #+-  02# -   2,

, 0 ! -  !$  #+-   23-  2$#-   02    2 0- 2D

2 ,  -2  ! - ,  ! , -    "7+ -F-  7 -  + 211 4-

32,-  45  #+-   + ! "#  : #+    $! "  3! # +

$ !3  #+-  ,2# -  ! $ " 0015  ! $ 2 7!0 5  !$  #+

! ,-   #!  #  

(
+ -  200- 21    #+"  211! : -,  #!  #+-  -F#-  #

, 72#-,  24!6 -    + - -  :  11 4-  !  ! ,-   2

#!  7!#    

     

/ / / / / / / / / / /  

                  &

  C  
@                               / / / /
/ / / / / / /  
      G

 98

   
  
       &

Ask CaseMinister about M/S Mohinder Singh & Co. v. Board of Trustees of the Port of Bombay

Your 24×7 legal assistant on WhatsApp answers with the judgments that apply, in English or Hindi. No signup needed.

Explain it in simple wordsDoes it help my case?Later judgments on thisStart free on the web
Questions about this judgment, or a case like it?Ask on WhatsApp